cakes & Pies

Our ice cream cakes and pies are made fresh on the premises. 

We always have an assortment available in our to go freezer.  But if you're looking for something special, something custom or something to wow your family and friends...  Call us, and let us make one up with your favorite flavors and toppings!  



Our Banana Pie features our Banana Cream Pie Ice Cream, and sits in a Graham Cracker Pie Shell.   It's topped with chocolate covered bananas and Nilla Wafers.

Blue Moon

Our Blue Moon Pie is our famous Blue Moon Ice Cream stuffed into an Oreo Pie Shell and topped with Fruit Loops!  So you can have it for breakfast, or dessert!! 

Cappuccino Chip

Our Cappuccino Chip Pie features our Cappuccino Chip Ice Cream in a Graham Cracker Pie Shell.  It's then decorated with a Chocolate puree lattice and mini chocolate chips.  

Cookies & Cream

Our Cookies & Cream Pie sits in an OREO Pie Shell.  It's filled with (you guessed it) Cookies & Cream Ice Cream, and finished with loads of OREO pieces.   

Mint Chocolate Chip

Our Mint Chocolate Chip Pie features our Premium Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream in an OREO Pie Shell.  It's finished off with Andies Mint Candies and mini chocolate chips, making this a Flavor Frenzy Favorite! 

NY Cherry

Our Cherry Pie features our NY Cherry Ice Cream in a Graham Cracker Pie Shell.  It's covered with chocolate covered Marschino Cherries and mini chocolate chips. 

Peanut Butter Cup

Our Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream  stuffed into a Graham Cracker Pie Crust and topped with crushed Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.   

Pecan Turtle

Our Pecan Turtle Pie starts off with Butter Pecan Ice Cream in a Graham Cracker Pie Shell.  It's then finished with Fudge, Caramel and Butter Roasted Georgia Pecans. 


Our Pistachio Ice Cream Pie features our premium Pistachio Ice Cream, sitting in a Graham Cracker Pie Shell.  It's then topped with whole Pastachios.   


Our Strawberry Pie features our finest Strawberry Ice Cream stuffed into a Graham Cracker Pie Shell.  It's then decorated with a Strawberry puree lattice and Chocolate covered Driscroll Strawberries.   

Our Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie is a seasonal Fall family favorite!  It's made from our premium pumpkin ice cream and sits in a graham cracker pie crust.   Available for a limited time only!  

Key Lime Pie

This is not an ice cream pie...  This is Uncle Harry's (almost famous) Key Lime Pie!  He's been making this pie for years, with a recipe given to him from a famous chef in Key West.  Just top it with a little whipped cream or a dollop of cool whip and this dessert makes the perfect compliment to any meal!   Please order in advance.

Are you looking for a custom pie that's not listed above? 

Give us a call...   If you can dream it, we can (probably) make it.   

If there's a specific pie you're looking for, please pre-order it at least 3 days prior

to when you're needing it, as not all pies are in stock and ready for same-day pick-up.



 Cake info coming soon...

© 2019 Flavor Frenzy